Lump-Sum Subcontractor Invoices: How to Get Scope 3 Quantities When the Invoice Shows Only Dollars
Turn a lump-sum subcontractor invoice into quantity-based Scope 3 lines using the dockets, claim schedules and hire records you already hold. Here is where the quantities sit, and how to treat the dollars that remain.
When a subcontractor's invoice is a lump sum, calculate Scope 3 from the documents around it. Delivery dockets, the claim schedule, hire timesheets and the subcontract's bill of quantities often hold the cubic metres and tonnes. Use those quantities with an emission factor. Apply a spend-based estimate only to what is left, and label it as an estimate.
That order matters. A lump-sum line tells you what you paid. It says nothing about how much concrete was poured or how long the excavator ran. Those facts were written down somewhere else on the project, usually by someone who had no idea they were recording carbon data.
We build carbon accounting software, and construction paperwork is where we spend most of our time. This post covers where the quantities sit for a lump-sum subcontract and how to handle the dollars that remain. It also covers what to write down so an assurer can follow your working.
Why a lump sum on its own leaves you with a spend-based number
The GHG Protocol's calculation guidance for Category 1 lists four methods for purchased goods and services. Two of them, supplier-specific and hybrid, need data collected from the supplier. The average-data method needs the mass or other units of what you bought. The spend-based method needs only the economic value.
A lump-sum invoice gives you economic value and nothing else. So on its own it supports only the spend-based method.
That has a cost in your disclosure. AASB S2 tells an entity to prioritise primary data, all else being equal (paragraph B47). It also asks how much of your Scope 3 is measured using inputs from specific activities within your value chain (paragraph B56). In our reading, a package estimated from dollars and an economy-wide factor does little for that share.
The standard doesn't ask for the impossible. Paragraph B39 asks for all reasonable and supportable information available at the reporting date without undue cost or effort. We think dockets already sitting in your project folders are hard to describe as undue effort.
Where the quantities sit for a lump-sum package
Take a hypothetical. A concrete placement subcontractor on a commercial build claims $186,000 for the month, supply and install, on one line. The invoice has no cubic metres on it.
The quantities for that month still exist. They are spread across paperwork your project team and accounts payable already hold.
| Document you already hold | Quantity it tends to carry | What it won't tell you |
|---|---|---|
| Delivery dockets signed on site | Cubic metres by mix, tonnes of reinforcement, litres of fuel | Who paid for the delivery |
| Schedule attached to the progress claim | Measured work items, where the contract has them | The mix or product behind each item |
| Subcontract bill of quantities or schedule of rates | Planned quantities by item | What was installed this period |
| Plant hire invoices and timesheets | Machine hours, sometimes litres | Fuel burn, unless it is stated |
| Pour records, weighbridge tickets and waste dockets | Dates, volumes and tonnes leaving site | Which emission factor applies |
Delivery dockets are the strongest of these. Under a supply-and-install package the batching plant still delivers to your site, and each load usually comes with a docket. The docket shows the mix and the volume, which is what a concrete factor needs. Our post on concrete emission factors for Scope 3 covers which factor to pick once you have the mix.
The claim schedule comes next. Many subcontracts are lump sum in price but measured in assessment, so the claim arrives with a breakdown of items completed. Where that breakdown carries quantities, it is activity data sitting behind the invoice.
The bill of quantities is the fallback, and a weaker one. It records what was planned. Use it only when nothing shows what was delivered, and say so in your working papers.
Units still need care once you have them. Concrete arrives in cubic metres and many factors are per tonne. Our guide to converting concrete m3 to tonnes explains when to convert and when a per-m3 factor avoids the problem.
Keep the dockets and the dollars from counting the same concrete
Once you take concrete volumes from the dockets, the $186,000 still sits in your accounts payable ledger. If your spend-based calculation also picks up that invoice, the same concrete is counted twice.
The fix is a decision per package, written down. Either the package is measured from documents and its invoices are left out of the spend-based run, or the reverse. A split is possible too, with quantities for the materials and spend for the labour and pumping that remain. For a split you need a defensible dollar figure for the remainder, and the claim schedule is the usual place to find one.
Here is our honest doubt. We don't know of a clean rule for splitting one lump sum between docketed materials and everything else. Contracts bundle things differently, so the person who knows the contract has to make that call. Software can show the overlap, and the boundary stays a human decision.
There is a second overlap to check. Diesel a subcontractor burns on a site you control may belong in your own Scope 1, outside Scope 3 altogether. We work through that test in Scope 3 double counting in construction, and the wider picture is in our subcontractor emissions guide.
What to do with the dollars that are left
Some packages have no quantities anywhere. Labour-only trades and design services are typical.
Spend-based is the right tool there, and AASB S2 expects estimation. Paragraph B57 presumes Scope 3 can be estimated reliably using secondary data and industry averages. Our guide to spend-based emissions accounting covers the factor sets and the inflation trap.
Two habits make the estimate easier to defend. Record that you looked for quantities and found none. Then label the line as spend-based in your working papers, so the split between measured and estimated packages stays visible. Paragraph 29(a)(iii) of AASB S2 asks for the measurement approach, inputs and assumptions, and that split is part of the answer.
Your first year can lean on estimates more than later years. AASB S2 lets an entity leave Scope 3 out of the first annual reporting period in which it applies the standard. The relief is in Appendix C, paragraph C4(b). From the next period the figure is in the report, and so is the share of it that rests on dollars.
How Carbonly handles a lump-sum package
Carbonly reads supplier invoices, dockets and utility bills in eight file formats, scanned PDFs and photos included. Documents arrive by email ingestion or by OneDrive and SharePoint sync, so the dockets in a project folder don't need retyping.
A multi-docket invoice becomes one record per docket. Each record keeps the verbatim line text as evidence. Five-tier material matching maps the line to an NGA factor or to a factor in the construction EPD library. Low-confidence matches go to a reviewer, and so do units that can't be converted without a figure the document never states.
Dollars are treated differently. Fee, hire, time and dollar-only adjustment lines are skipped. Hire and time lines on a plant hire invoice fall in that group, so Carbonly does not read machine hours from them. Spend-based Scope 3 is floored to low data quality.
An evidence pack is designed to support the assurance work. The reporting entity and its assurer stay responsible for the figure. If a consultant prepares your inventory, the same workflow applies, and the boundary calls stay with the consultant and your project team. There is more on the mechanics on how it works, and the Scope 3 topic hub collects the related guides.
Start with one package
Pick the largest lump-sum subcontract on one live project. Pull last month's claim and the dockets delivered against it. Then count how many of the dollars you can now explain with a cubic metre or a tonne.
For future subcontracts, ask procurement to require a quantity breakdown with each progress claim. That changes a claim format the subcontractor already produces, and it adds no questionnaire.
If you'd like to run that package's paperwork through Carbonly, book a 30-minute walkthrough at calendly.com/carbonly/30min or email hello@carbonly.ai.
FAQ
How do I calculate Scope 3 emissions from a lump-sum subcontractor invoice? Start with the documents around the invoice. Delivery dockets, the claim schedule and hire timesheets often hold cubic metres, tonnes or machine hours. Multiply those quantities by a matching emission factor. Use a spend-based estimate only for the part with no quantities, and label it as an estimate.
Where do I find quantities when a supplier invoice shows only a dollar amount? Look at delivery dockets signed on site, the schedule attached to the progress claim, and plant hire timesheets. The subcontract's bill of quantities is a fallback. It shows planned quantities, which may differ from what was installed in the period.
Can I use a spend-based estimate for subcontractors under AASB S2? In our reading, yes. AASB S2 paragraph B57 presumes Scope 3 can be estimated reliably using secondary data and industry averages. Paragraph B47 also tells entities to prioritise primary data, all else being equal. So use quantities where your documents hold them, and disclose which packages rest on spend.
How do I avoid double counting when I use both dockets and invoices? Decide per package whether it is measured from documents or estimated from spend, and record the decision. If concrete volumes come from dockets, leave that concrete's dollars out of the spend-based calculation. Where a package is split, keep a note of how the remaining dollar figure was set.
Do I need to ask the subcontractor for anything? Often no, for past periods. Dockets and claims are often already in your project and accounts payable records. For future packages, a quantity breakdown on each progress claim makes the same job easier.
What does Carbonly do with fee, hire and dollar-only adjustment lines? It skips them, along with time lines. Spend-based Scope 3 is floored to low data quality.
Related articles
- Scope 3 Emissions Software in Australia: Supplier Invoices Turned Into Line Items You Can Show an Auditor
- Scope 3 Double Counting: The Same Tonne of Concrete, Counted Twice
- Carbon Accounting Supply Chain: The Multi-Currency Problem
- Embodied Carbon in Buildings: What Australian Builders Need
- Handwritten or Blurry Delivery Dockets: How to Use Them for Emissions Data