NGA vs GHG Protocol: Why Australian Carbon Accounting Needs Both
NGA tells you the factor; GHG Protocol tells you the scope. The same diesel invoice feeds NGER at AR5 and AASB S2 at AR6 only if your ledger stores the activity data, not the CO2-e total. Here is how to keep the two submissions tied without double-counting Scope 2.
A common question from finance teams sitting down to their first AASB S2 disclosure is a variation of the same theme. We already report under NGER. Why are our numbers different in the AASB S2 draft? Which one is right?
Both are right. They answer different questions. The numbers move between them by design.
Australia has two live carbon reporting frameworks running in parallel through 2026 and 2027. The National Greenhouse and Energy Reporting scheme, run by the Clean Energy Regulator under the NGER Act 2007, is a mandatory submission for corporations that cross the threshold. AASB S2 is the mandatory climate-related financial disclosure standard issued in September 2024, phased in for Group 1 entities from 1 January 2025 and expanding to Group 2 in FY starting 1 July 2026 and Group 3 in FY starting 1 July 2027. They share activity data. They do not share methodology.
The activity data lives in one place. The methodology diverges. If you build the ledger correctly, the same litre of diesel from the same fuel supplier invoice can render into an NGER submission and an AASB S2 disclosure without you touching it twice. If you build it incorrectly, you will double-count Scope 2, misclassify purchased goods, or worse, submit an NGER number that does not tie to your assured disclosure. That last one is the hardest to explain to an assurer.
What NGA actually is
The National Greenhouse Accounts factors, published by the Department of Climate Change, Energy, the Environment and Water (DCCEEW), are an emission factor library. Nothing more, nothing less. The current edition, NGA 2025, covers fuels, electricity, transport, waste, fugitives and industrial processes, including the liquid fuel factors (automotive diesel, unleaded petrol, aviation kerosene, LPG and the rest) that dominate Scope 1 in fleet-heavy industries.
Grid electricity factors are published state by state. NGA 2025 lists Victoria at 0.78 kg CO2-e/kWh, New South Wales and ACT at 0.64, Tasmania at 0.20. Those numbers move each year as generation mixes decarbonise. Overwrite last year's factor in your ledger and the audit trail for last year's figure goes with it.
What NGA does not do is tell you which scope an emission belongs in, which reporting boundary you should draw, or how to categorise a Scope 3 transaction. Those questions sit elsewhere.
What GHG Protocol actually is
The GHG Protocol Corporate Standard, published jointly by the World Resources Institute and the World Business Council for Sustainable Development, is the categorisation and boundary framework. It defines Scope 1 as direct emissions from owned or controlled sources, Scope 2 as indirect emissions from purchased energy, and Scope 3 as everything else in the value chain. The companion Corporate Value Chain (Scope 3) Standard breaks Scope 3 into 15 categories, from purchased goods and services (Category 1) through end-of-life treatment of sold products (Category 12) and franchises (Category 14).
The GHG Protocol tells you where an emission belongs. It does not tell you what number to multiply the activity data by. It defers to jurisdictional factor libraries for that.
The two frameworks are complementary. NGA answers "what is the factor". GHG Protocol answers "what scope does it belong in". Confuse the two and you have made a category error that will surface at limited assurance.
Where NGER Measurement Determination sits
Between the activity data and the NGA factor library sits the NGER (Measurement) Determination 2008 (as amended). This is the legally binding methodology document that specifies how NGER-reporting corporations must calculate emissions. Method 1 uses default emission factors, which the NGA Factors republish in a more usable form. Higher-tier methods (Method 2 and Method 3) require sampling and analysis.
The Determination is Australian law and is amended most years. NGER uses IPCC AR5 (2013) global warming potentials, set in regulation 2.02 of the NGER Regulations. Methane at 28. Nitrous oxide at 265. The reporter does not choose the GWP set. The Regulations do.
If you are above an NGER threshold (a facility at 25 kt CO2-e or 100 TJ of energy, or a corporate group at 50 kt CO2-e or 200 TJ), you report under this framework by 31 October each year. This year 31 October falls on a Saturday, so the 2025-26 report is due by midnight AEDT on Monday 2 November 2026, and the CER has said there are no extensions. Our NGER October 2026 deadline guide covers the last weeks before lodgement. Records must be kept for five years from the end of the reporting year. Civil penalties are set in penalty units ($364 each from 1 July 2026).
Where AASB S2 sits
AASB S2 is the Australian implementation of IFRS S2 issued by the ISSB. It is a financial disclosure standard, sitting alongside the financial statements, and it points to the GHG Protocol Corporate Standard for measuring and categorising emissions.
Scope 2 is disclosed on the location-based method, with information about any contractual instruments (GreenPower, LGCs, PPAs) alongside it. The standard also asks you to describe your measurement approach, inputs and assumptions, which is where the reconciliation problem gets interesting.
The critical technical difference is the GWP set. IFRS S2 (and therefore AASB S2) requires the most recent GWPs from the IPCC assessment cycle, which is currently AR6 (2021). AR6 revises methane up to 29.8 for fossil sources and 27.0 for non-fossil sources. Nitrous oxide moves to 273. That is not a small change for anyone with material methane exposure.
The AR5 vs AR6 GWP problem
Here is the gap. The same tonne of fugitive methane produces:
- Under NGER (Method 1, AR5): 28 t CO2-e
- Under AASB S2 (AR6, fossil): 29.8 t CO2-e
Same molecule, same measurement, two different disclosures. Multiply that across a gas distribution network, a landfill, or a coal mine ventilation shaft and the reconciliation gap gets material fast. The AASB approved limited jurisdictional relief in AASB S2025-1 on 15 December 2025. It lets an NGER reporter use AR5 GWPs in its AASB S2 disclosure for the portion of emissions NGER covers, without recalculation. According to the AASB, it applies to annual periods beginning on or after 1 January 2027, with earlier application permitted. The relief does not reach emissions outside NGER's scope, which includes Scope 3. The reconciliation is unavoidable at the boundary.
If your ledger stores only the final CO2-e number, you are stuck. If your ledger stores the activity quantity, the gas species, and applies the GWP at render time, you can produce both disclosures from the same source data. That architectural decision is the whole game.
The Scope 2 dual-render problem
Scope 2 is an easy place for a first-year reporter to double-count. NGA gives you a location-based grid factor for each state, and a single national residual mix factor (0.81 kg CO2-e/kWh in NGA 2025) for the market-based method. GHG Protocol Scope 2 guidance asks for both figures where contractual instruments exist.
AASB S2 makes the location-based figure the required one. Every method starts from the same underlying kWh number.
The failure mode is straightforward. Reporter buys 2,000 MWh of GreenPower for a Victorian site. Reporter enters 2,000 MWh under Scope 2 with the location-based factor (0.78) and again under Scope 2 market-based with a zero-emissions factor. Now they have two Scope 2 records for the same electricity. If those two records both flow into the total, that is a double-count. If the reporter then also claims the LGCs under a separate voluntary Scope 2 reduction, that is a triple-count. We wrote about this failure pattern at length because it is an easy mistake to make in a first-year disclosure.
The right architecture stores kWh once, then dual-renders. Location-based render uses the state grid factor. Market-based render adjusts for cancelled LGCs and GreenPower purchases against the residual mix. The reporter picks which is primary for their submission (AASB S2 says location-based) and the other becomes supplementary.
The Scope 3 categorisation problem
Scope 3 is where GHG Protocol and NGER diverge most sharply. NGER covers Scope 1 and Scope 2 only. GHG Protocol Category 1 is purchased goods and services, upstream of the reporting entity, and for many construction and manufacturing companies it is the largest single category.
A common mis-classification is this. A construction company treats subcontractor fuel as Scope 3 Category 4 (upstream transportation and distribution). In our reading it usually belongs in Category 1 (purchased goods and services), because the subcontractor delivered a construction service rather than a transport service. The activity is the same. The category label is different. That label matters because Scope 3 categorisation drives how the disclosure is structured and what a limited assurance auditor will test against under ASSA 5010.
NGA does publish some Scope 3 factors, such as the upstream emissions of fuels and grid electricity. The boundary drawing is still a GHG Protocol Corporate Value Chain Standard exercise. An NGA lookup will not settle it.
How the reconciliation actually works in a defensible ledger
The reconciliation is decided by how the ledger is built. Leave it to the report-render step and it gets harder every year. Here is the shape that works:
Store activity data at the source-document level. The fuel supplier's invoice records 4,850 litres of automotive diesel delivered to project site X on date Y. That is the primary record. Not a monthly aggregate. Not a spend line. The invoice itself, with its total, GST, supplier ABN, delivery address and product code, sits behind the emission record.
Record the factor version on every record. Each emission record carries the factor version it was calculated with. When the next NGA edition is released, historic records keep their original factor. An ASSA 5010 assurance practitioner may ask for evidence of the factor source at the record level.
Render NGER with AR5 GWPs. For the NGER submission, gas-species records apply AR5 multipliers (CH4 at 28, N2O at 265).
Render AASB S2 with AR6 GWPs. For the AASB S2 disclosure, the same gas-species records apply AR6 multipliers, with jurisdictional relief applied where AASB S2025-1 permits.
Preserve methodology labels per record. AASB S2 asks you to explain your measurement approach and inputs. Give every record a methodology tag: activity-based, hybrid, supplier-specific, average-data, spend-based. When the auditor asks how much of the Scope 3 disclosure is spend-based, the answer is a query, not a spreadsheet exercise.
The same structure serves internal management reporting too, because the categorisation lives on the record rather than on the report.
What you get when NGER and AASB S2 run off one ledger
With Carbonly, the NGER report and the AASB S2 report come from the same ledger records. The NGER XML export is a reference document for entering your EERS report, and the AASB S2 report exports to PDF or Word.
Every emission record keeps the emission factor version it was calculated with.
The ledger calculates on AR5, which is what regulation 2.02 of the NGER Regulations requires and what AASB S2025-1 permits for the NGER-covered portion of an AASB S2 disclosure, so both documents run off the same activity data with no re-entry. The ledger writes AR5 only, so an AR6 view of whatever the relief does not cover has to be prepared separately.
The five-tier material matching maps supplier line items to NGA factors, and low-confidence matches go to a reviewer. The evidence pack export gives an ASSA 5010 auditor the trail from the emission back to the invoice.
Spend-based Scope 3 records are floored to low data quality, so activity-based diesel from a fuel invoice looks different in the ledger to spend-based Category 1 procurement from an ERP export, even when both roll up to the same total.
Consultants leading first-year AASB S2 engagements can use the platform as the evidence layer under their advisory work. The workflow surfaces the source document for every number in the disclosure, which is what turns an assurance conversation from a spreadsheet argument into a records review.
None of this makes the framework difference go away. It just moves it from a manual reconciliation problem to a reporting-layer one, with the audit trail intact.
FAQ
Is NGA the same as the GHG Protocol?
No. NGA is an Australian emission factor library published by DCCEEW, currently in its 2025 edition. The GHG Protocol is a global boundary and categorisation standard published by WRI and WBCSD. NGA tells you what number to multiply activity data by. GHG Protocol tells you which scope and category that emission sits in.
Does AASB S2 accept NGA emission factors?
AASB S2 does not prescribe a factor library. It points to the GHG Protocol for categorisation and to the latest IPCC GWPs (currently AR6). In our reading, NGA factors are a reasonable basis for Australian activity data, with AR6 GWPs applied to gas-species emissions. AASB S2025-1 permits AR5 GWPs for NGER-covered portions. Confirm your approach with your assurance provider.
What is the difference between AR5 and AR6 for methane?
IPCC AR5 (2013) sets methane GWP at 28 over 100 years. IPCC AR6 (2021) revises this to 29.8 for fossil methane and 27.0 for non-fossil methane. Nitrous oxide moves from 265 (AR5) to 273 (AR6). NGER uses AR5. AASB S2 requires AR6, apart from the NGER-covered portion that AASB S2025-1 relief lets you report on AR5. The same activity data produces different disclosures under each framework.
Do I need to submit separately under NGER and AASB S2?
Yes. If you are above an NGER threshold (a facility at 25 kt CO2-e or 100 TJ, or a corporate group at 50 kt CO2-e or 200 TJ), you report to the Clean Energy Regulator using the NGER Measurement Determination methodology. The 2025-26 report is due by midnight AEDT on Monday 2 November 2026, with no extensions. If you are a Group 1, 2 or 3 entity under the ASRS regime, you also disclose under AASB S2. The two run in parallel with their own frameworks. An NGER reporter that lodges financial reports under Chapter 2M of the Corporations Act falls into Group 1 or Group 2, depending on its size and emissions.
Can one platform produce both?
It can, if the platform stores activity data with the factor version on each record and keeps the gas quantities behind each CO2-e figure. Without that, the reporter ends up keeping two ledgers. Carbonly calculates on AR5 only. Ask us, or any vendor, which GWP views the reporting layer produces today.
What to do next
If you are inside a first AASB S2 disclosure and the NGER numbers do not tie, do not adjust the outputs. Look at the ledger. If the activity data is stored as CO2-e totals, the reconciliation cannot be automated and you will fight this problem every year. If the activity data is stored at the source-document level with methodology labels and the factor version on each record, the reconciliation becomes a reporting step.
We keep a written explainer of the NGA library with the state-by-state factor tables and a walkthrough of the AR5/AR6 methane problem that shows the reconciliation numerically. The Scope 2 calculation guide covers the location vs market-based dual-render in more detail. If you are preparing a first-year disclosure, the CFO playbook for first AASB S2 walks the process end to end. If your NGER report is still open, start with the NGER October 2026 deadline guide.
Pricing is a per-project licence with an A$100 per month workspace minimum and no per-seat fees. Get in touch at hello@carbonly.ai.
Related articles
- AASB S2 Reporting Software for Group 2 and Group 3: Disclosure Figures Your Assurer Can Trace
- NGER Reporting Software in Australia: Every Figure in Your Submission Traced to Its Source
- Renewable Energy Certificate Retirement and LGC Surrender Tracking
- What the Beach Energy Enforceable Undertaking Teaches AASB S2 Reporters
- The 12-Month Operational Plan for Australian ASRS Group 2 Reporters (Starting Now)