Why Carbonly Is the Best Carbon Accounting Software in Australia

Plenty of carbon accounting platforms in Australia still expect you to key in consumption data, or were built for global markets and adapted afterwards. We built Carbonly the other way around: Australian mandatory reporting first, and document extraction as the foundation everything else sits on.

Carbonly.ai Team November 12, 2026 18 min read
Carbon AccountingCarbonlyASRSNGERSoftware
Why Carbonly Is the Best Carbon Accounting Software in Australia

We're going to make our case and then spend the next 2,000 words backing it up with specifics you can check.

Our view is that Carbonly is the strongest fit in Australia for a company facing mandatory climate reporting under NGER, AASB S2 or both. That is our opinion, not a measured fact, and it rests on three things you can verify for yourself: one integrated platform, from AI document extraction through NGER threshold tracking, JV consolidation and Safeguard trajectory checks; an architecture built for Australian reporting rules rather than adapted to them; and a foundation we deliberately built first, which is getting accurate emissions data out of the messy documents Australian companies deal with every day. AGL electricity bills, Origin gas invoices, council water statements, waste manifests. Without templates, without CSV uploads, without manual keying.

Every competitive statement below reflects publicly available vendor documentation as at 9 September 2026. Where we could not find documentation of a capability, we say that rather than asserting the capability is absent.

Your sustainability team has a data entry problem

The BCG and CO2 AI Carbon Survey found that only 7% of large companies comprehensively measure their greenhouse gas emissions. Seven percent. Not because they don't care - because the data collection process is so painful that most organisations give up before they finish.

The shape of that failure is well documented, and it looks like this. A sustainability manager at a mid-market construction company is told to prepare for ASRS Group 2 reporting. They inherit a shared drive full of utility bill PDFs covering dozens of sites, in formats that change from supplier to supplier. They open the first AGL electricity invoice, squint at it, find the kWh figure buried between demand charges and solar feed-in credits, type it into a spreadsheet, and move on to the next one. A few invoices in, they're already wondering if they misread the unit on an earlier one. By the time they work through the stack, they've lost real time to retyping numbers from PDFs into cells - and they haven't calculated a single emission yet.

None of that time goes to analysing emissions, building reduction plans, or preparing for assurance. It goes to typing numbers from PDFs into cells. Advertised salary ranges for a sustainability analyst in Australia sit around $85,000-$110,000, and industry surveys consistently report a large share of that kind of role's time going to data collection rather than analysis. However a given company's own split breaks down, the direction is the same: a meaningful share of a skilled analyst's time and salary goes toward re-keying invoice data rather than anything that reduces emissions.

We built Carbonly because that's indefensible.

What "automated" actually means (and doesn't)

Here's what frustrates us about this market. "Automated" is close to universal in Australian carbon accounting marketing. Go look at what the word covers in practice.

Across the vendor documentation we have read, "automated" usually means one of three things. You can connect your accounting software (Xero, MYOB) and the platform will try to estimate emissions from spend data. You can upload a CSV or Excel file with consumption data already extracted and the platform will apply emission factors. Or you can type numbers into a form and the platform will do the maths.

That's not automation. That's a spreadsheet with a better UI and a login page.

The hard part of carbon accounting was never the multiplication. Multiply kWh by an emission factor - any calculator can do that. The hard part is getting the kWh figure out of a scanned PDF where the format changes every time your energy retailer redesigns their invoice. The hard part is knowing whether that figure is total consumption or just peak, whether it's kWh or MWh, whether the billing period aligns with your reporting period. That's where the errors creep in, and it is the step a spend-based or CSV-first workflow never has to take.

Carbonly doesn't skip it. Our AI Document Processing Engine - the core of the platform and our primary competitive moat - accepts PDF, CSV, Excel (including multi-sheet workbooks), Word, PowerPoint, RTF, and images - eight formats in all. As at 9 September 2026 we could not find public documentation of another Australian carbon accounting platform accepting this breadth of input; if we have missed one, tell us and we will update this post. We use multimodal AI vision to read the actual document - the physical PDF or image of your utility bill - the way a human would. Our AI understands layout, context, and relationships between fields. When a retailer changes its bill format, we don't need a template update. The model reads the new layout and extracts what matters: consumption quantity, unit of measurement, billing period, meter number, site address.

Then comes our 5-tier material matching system - the part that turns extracted text into the correct emission factor. First, it tries an exact name match against our material library (NGA factors, or a construction EPD factor library). If that fails, it matches by emission factor code. Then by material alias. Then by fuzzy text similarity. And finally, if all four deterministic methods fail, it escalates to AI-assisted matching with confidence scoring, so you can review low-confidence matches in bulk before they hit your emissions register. When a reviewer corrects a match or assigns a material to an unmatched line, that line text is saved as an alias on the material for your organisation only, so later documents with the same wording match through it. This is alias learning. Accepting a match that was already right does not add an alias, and we are not going to put a percentage on how much it helps, because that depends entirely on your document mix.

The full extraction pipeline includes classification (identifying the document type), extraction (pulling the data), validation (2,450,000 kWh for a small Parramatta office? Flagged by our deterministic anomaly checks, which run daily and after each document batch), normalisation (converting units), emission calculation (applying the correct NGA Factor), and a complete audit trail linking every final number back to its source document.

Upload the bill. Get the emission figure. With a full audit trail the whole way through.

Built for Australia. Not adapted for Australia

This is where we think global platforms are weakest for Australian reporters, and it's a distinction that matters more than most buyers realise.

Persefoni is a good product. They have an AI copilot and their published ISSB alignment is solid. They are also a US-headquartered company selling into a global market. Reviewing their public documentation as at 9 September 2026, we could not find NGA Factors, state-based Australian grid factors, NGER output formats or AASB S2 disclosure structures described as core architecture rather than regional coverage. That distinction matters here, because the Australian numbers are not interchangeable with anyone else's: NGA Factors are reissued annually by DCCEEW, and the grid factor runs from NSW (0.64 kg CO2-e/kWh) to Victoria (0.78) to Tasmania (0.20). We've laid out the full feature-by-feature comparison separately: Carbonly vs Persefoni.

IBM Envizi began in Sydney before IBM acquired it in a publicly reported January 2022 deal, which is ironic. It's a capable enterprise platform with a very large global factor library. IBM does not publish a public price list for Envizi. Publicly reported figures suggest enterprise-tier annual contracts and multi-month implementations; confirm current pricing and timelines with the vendor. Our observation is about fit rather than quality: a 300-person company does not need tens of thousands of global emission factors. They need the correct NGA Factors for their operations, applied to their actual utility bills, producing output their auditor can verify. Envizi is a fighter jet when you need a ute.

Carbonly was built from day one for Australian mandatory reporters. Our NGER support is native, meaning NGER concepts sit in the data model rather than in an export layer: facility and corporate-group threshold status is computed from the ledger. As at 9 September 2026, the other Australian platforms whose public documentation describes NGER-specific reporting built into the product are NetNada, Unravel, and EnviroCapture.

Our team has 15+ years in enterprise data platforms across the Australian resources sector, including exposure to NGER audits, so we have seen the kind of evidence those reviews look for. A common mistake is applying the wrong state-based emission factor - for example, using the national average (0.62) instead of Victoria's factor (0.78), which understates emissions by around 20%.

That experience is baked into every module. Our emissions tracking covers Scope 1, Scope 2, and Scope 3, with spend-based Scope 3 floored to low data quality so estimates are visible as estimates. Our material library matches to NGA factors or a construction EPD factor library, and when a line can't be matched with confidence it goes to a reviewer instead of being guessed. We use the 2025 NGA Factors. We calculate with state-based grid emission factors. Each record keeps the emission factor version applied, and an evidence pack is produced for assurance.

We produce NGER-aligned output on AR5 Global Warming Potential values, which is what the NGER Measurement Determination requires. AASB S2 directs reporters to the latest IPCC assessment, which is AR6 - a different GWP set, not just a different report template. If you're an NGER reporter who's been pulled into ASRS Group 2 - and plenty have, since NGER registration is an automatic pathway - that AR5/AR6 gap is worth raising with your auditor directly rather than assuming any one tool closes it for you silently. If you're evaluating against one report specifically, we've broken the buyer's checklist out by report type: NGER reporting software and AASB S2 reporting software.

The Australian market, honestly

We wrote a full comparison of carbon accounting software in Australia a few weeks ago, and we tried to be fair. Here's the shorter version with updated observations.

Avarni is, in our view, a strong option for enterprise buyers, and their public materials put real weight on supplier engagement tools. Their AI handles large datasets - they claim to process a million rows in two and a half hours. If your primary challenge is Scope 3 across hundreds of suppliers, Avarni deserves a serious look. Where we would push a buyer to test them hardest is document-level extraction. Their published material emphasises structured data ingestion at volume, and as at 9 September 2026 we could not find public documentation of extraction from scanned utility bill PDFs as a primary input path. If that is your starting point, ask them to demonstrate it on your own bills. As at the same date we also could not find public documentation of anomaly detection or joint venture consolidation in their material. Both are built into Carbonly.

NetNada has moved fast in the SME space. They claim 1,000+ businesses. Their Carbon Data Uploader now supports PDF invoices and utility bills with OCR and AI-powered column mapping, which is a genuine improvement. For a company under 100 employees doing basic NGER reporting, they're a solid choice. The design difference worth understanding is that OCR plus column mapping depends on the layout being recognisable, so the question to put to any vendor using that approach is what happens to a bill it has not seen before. Carbonly's 5-tier material matching (exact name, code, alias, fuzzy text, AI escalation) with confidence scoring is built to degrade in stages rather than fail outright, and to surface low-confidence matches for review instead of silently guessing. As at 9 September 2026 we could not find public documentation of anomaly detection or JV consolidation in NetNada's material. For companies processing hundreds of documents per quarter, how a pipeline behaves on the documents it did not expect matters more than how it behaves on the ones it did.

Trace has expanded their compliance positioning since we last looked. They now market ASRS and ISSB alignment alongside their original offset marketplace. We respect the hustle. Their public offering still combines measurement with offset supply, and our view is that where a vendor both measures a footprint and sells the credits applied against it, a buyer should ask how that is governed internally. That is an opinion about incentive design, not an allegation about their conduct. More on why we took a different position below.

Sumday has carved out an interesting niche with accountants and advisors. The Xero integration and advisor training model is clever: let the existing accounting profession handle carbon accounting alongside financial accounting. Whether accountants want to own carbon compliance is still an open question, but if your firm's accountant is keen, Sumday is worth considering. Worth noting: as at 9 September 2026 we could not find public documentation of AI document extraction, NGER-specific reporting or anomaly detection in Sumday's material. It is aimed at a narrower problem than Carbonly, which for some buyers is exactly the right trade.

How we actually compare: the feature matrix

We've seen enough vague "we do everything" claims on vendor websites to last a lifetime. Here's a concrete, feature-level comparison.

Read the table with its limits in mind. It records what we could find in each vendor's public documentation as at 9 September 2026, and nothing more. "Not documented" means we could not find published evidence of the capability on that date. It does not mean the vendor lacks it: products change, and plenty of capability never reaches a public feature page. Verify anything that will drive your decision directly with the vendor. If any vendor listed here believes we've misread their published material, we'll correct it. Email hello@carbonly.ai.

Feature Carbonly NetNada Avarni Sumday Greenly Persefoni
AI Document Extraction (multi-format) Yes - 8 formats, 5-tier matching Partial (OCR) Yes (ML) Not documented Not documented Not documented
NGER Compliance (native) Yes Yes Implied Not documented Not documented Not documented
AASB S2 / ASRS Ready Yes Yes Yes Unclear Not documented Not documented
Anomaly Detection (rules-based) Yes - deterministic, daily and after each batch Not documented Not documented Not documented Not documented Yes
JV Consolidation Yes - operational, financial or equity share Not documented Not documented Not documented Not documented Not documented
Scope 1/2/3 Yes Yes Yes Partial Yes Yes
Full Source-to-Report Audit Trail Yes Partial Partial Not documented Not documented Yes

One thing stands out to us: JV consolidation, which matters for resources, infrastructure, and property companies with joint venture structures, is a capability we could not find documented in any of the platforms above on that date. We built it because Australian resources and infrastructure operators work in that structure.

For context on pricing: neither Watershed nor Salesforce publishes a public price list for their carbon products. Publicly reported figures suggest Watershed contracts in the range of roughly US$25,000 to US$175,000 per year (about A$37,000 to A$264,000) and Salesforce Net Zero Cloud roughly US$32,000 to US$140,000 per year (about A$48,000 to A$210,000). Confirm current pricing with those vendors rather than relying on either figure. Carbonly's pricing is published: a per-project licence with a $100/month workspace minimum and no per-seat fees, scaling to large multi-site deployments, with the same AI engine and the same audit trail at every tier. We don't believe you should need a six-figure budget to get accurate emissions data, and a growing SME shouldn't have to change platforms to get there.

Why we don't sell offsets (and you should care)

This is a philosophical position not everyone agrees with. We think that's fine.

When a platform both measures your emissions and sells you offsets to reduce them, the incentive structure is broken. The measurement arm wants accuracy. The offset arm wants sales. Those two goals don't always align. A 2023 investigation reported by The Guardian, Die Zeit and SourceMaterial concluded that more than 90% of the Verra rainforest offset credits it examined were unlikely to represent real emission reductions. Verra publicly disputed the findings. The ACCC has named greenwashing as an enforcement priority and has pursued misleading carbon neutral claims. In 2025 the Federal Court ordered a $10.5 million penalty against a superannuation fund following ASIC proceedings over investments in areas its own ESG policy represented as "eliminated or restricted."

If your measurement tool has a financial interest in the offsets it recommends, ask how that interest is managed.

Carbonly measures. That's it. We don't sell offsets. We don't recommend offset providers. We don't take a commission on credits. Your emissions data is your emissions data, and nobody in our business has an incentive to make it look any different than it is.

The audit trail problem nobody talks about

Beach Energy - an ASX-listed oil and gas company - signed an enforceable undertaking with the Clean Energy Regulator in July 2025 after "inadvertently misstating components of its NGER reports" across multiple periods. Under the terms published by the regulator, the remediation includes three years of assurance audits at the company's own expense and external help rebuilding its data collection systems.

As published, the undertaking focuses on data collection systems. That is the point worth taking from it: the weak link is often the chain from source document to reported figure.

Under ASRS, this gets more dangerous. The modified liability period does not shelter Scope 1 and Scope 2 figures the way it shelters Scope 3, scenario analysis and transition plan statements, so those numbers carry full exposure from the start. Directors face personal liability for materially inaccurate figures, and Corporations Act civil penalties for a corporation run into the tens of millions of dollars or a percentage of annual turnover depending on the provision engaged. Check the applicable provision with your own advisers rather than relying on a single headline figure. The ANAO found that 72% of the 545 NGER reports it examined contained errors, with 17% having significant errors.

Every figure in Carbonly traces from the reported emission number back through the calculation chain to the source document. Not a spreadsheet cell reference. The actual PDF. Ledger writes carry typed audit events with timestamps and user attribution, designed to support the record-keeping evidence a Clean Energy Regulator review or an ASRS assurance engagement asks for. Each record keeps the source document, the verbatim line text, the material it was matched to and the factor version applied, so your auditor can go from a reported figure back to the bill where a figure like 12,450 kWh appears. That is what makes a walk-through fast. It is also a chain that can only exist if the platform handled the source document in the first place, which is why we put document extraction at the foundation rather than bolting it on.

If you're still processing utility bills manually, you might want to understand how Scope 2 calculations actually work end-to-end before your next reporting cycle.

What we're still building (honestly)

We're not going to pretend Carbonly does everything perfectly yet. That would be its own form of greenwashing.

Our Scope 3 coverage is still developing. Spend-based estimation works, and those records are floored to low data quality. But Categories 1 and 2 - purchased goods and services, capital goods - require supplier-specific data that's genuinely difficult to collect at scale. Spend-based estimates are rough. And "rough" isn't great when you're facing assurance from year two. We have a Supplier Portal and a Supplier Data Chase Agent that follows up on a configured cadence, but we're not going to claim we've cracked Scope 3 across 500 suppliers. We've written a fuller buyer's checklist for this specific problem: Scope 3 emissions software in Australia.

Our climate risk scenario analysis tools for AASB S2 strategy disclosures are still maturing. Generic scenarios that don't reflect actual business operations are a known pitfall for first-year reporters. We don't want to ship generic scenario templates and call it done. We'd rather take longer and get it right.

Our direct ERP and accounting connectors are still expanding. If you need SAP, Oracle and Workday connections live on day one, other platforms have a head start, and our answer today is that we import from any system that can produce a document or an export rather than that we have a native connector for each.

Here's what we will stand behind: AI document processing in eight file formats, five-tier material matching with alias learning, emissions tracking across all scopes, NGER threshold status from the ledger, deterministic anomaly checks, JV consolidation, the Safeguard Trajectory Check, emissions forecasting and intensity targets, email ingestion and OneDrive and SharePoint sync, the Supplier Portal, period locking with restatement reasons, and an evidence pack for assurance. We built the document layer first, on purpose, because if the number coming out of the bill is wrong then nothing downstream can fix it.

Scales from ten bills to thousands

A common worry for mid-market companies is whether a tool built for SMEs will handle growth, or whether an enterprise tool will be overkill for their size.

Carbonly's AI pipeline is the same whether you upload ten documents or several thousand. That is what the platform is designed for, because a large Australian construction or infrastructure operation generates far more source documents than a team can key in. There's no pricing tier where the extraction pipeline changes or the audit trail gets less detailed. A property manager tracking emissions across 5 sites uses the same engine as an infrastructure company with 200 facilities.

And the platform scales with organisational complexity, not just volume. Projects support multi-facility structures, with documents arriving through OneDrive and SharePoint sync or email ingestion, and suppliers submitting through the Supplier Portal scoped per project. Intensity targets and emissions forecasting let you track progress as you grow. Carbonly has no affiliation with the SBTi; target validation is a process you run with the SBTi directly.

For companies with joint venture structures - and there are a lot of them in Australian resources, infrastructure, and property - our JV consolidation handles operational control, financial control and equity share. Report your 40% share of a joint venture's emissions without manual calculations, without spreadsheet gymnastics, without asking your JV partner to use the same software. As at 9 September 2026 we could not find public documentation of an equivalent capability in the Australian platforms we reviewed.

This matters because Australian mandatory reporting is expanding. Group 1 entities (two of: 500+ employees, $500M+ revenue, $1B+ gross assets) reported from January 2025. Group 2 (two of: 250+ employees, $200M+ revenue, $500M+ gross assets, or a registered NGER reporter) started from July 2026 and is live now. Group 3 (two of: 100+ employees, $50M+ revenue, $25M+ gross assets) follows from July 2027. If you're Group 3 today, you might be Group 2 tomorrow after an acquisition. The tool you choose now needs to handle what you'll need in three years, not just what you need today.

The module we rarely see elsewhere

One capability in Carbonly is rarely documented in Australian-focused competitors' public material, based on our review in September 2026. It's worth calling out because it solves a real problem that companies currently handle in spreadsheets, separate tools, or not at all.

Anomaly Detection. When your Scope 2 electricity emissions at one facility suddenly jump 300% quarter-on-quarter, you want to know about it before your auditor does. Carbonly's anomaly detection applies configurable statistical and rules-based checks with severity levels and triggers an investigation workflow. It is deterministic by design, so a flag can be explained to an assurer as a rule rather than a model output. As at 9 September 2026, the other platforms whose public documentation describes comparable automated anomaly detection are BraveGen and Persefoni. This is the class of control that helps catch a data error in the quarter it happens, rather than in an assurance walk-through or a regulator's review.

The real test

Forget everything we've written here. Do this instead.

Gather your last quarter of electricity and gas bills - the actual PDFs from AGL, Origin, EnergyAustralia, whoever your retailers are. Include the weird ones. The council water bill with the table layout that makes no sense. The gas invoice from a regional supplier that looks like it was designed in 1997.

Send them to us. Send them to Avarni. Send them to NetNada. Send them to whoever else you're evaluating.

Ask each vendor: show me the extracted data, the emission factor applied, the calculation, and the audit trail back to the source document. Time how long it takes. Check whether the state-based emission factor is correct. Check whether the billing period aligns with your reporting period. Check whether the audit trail actually goes back to the document or just to a data entry screen.

That test will tell you more than any blog post, including this one.

But we're confident enough in the result that we're the ones suggesting it.

If you want to run it, send your documents to hello@carbonly.ai and we'll process them for free. No credit card, no sales call required. Just your bills and our AI, and you judge the output.

Quick Answers

Does Carbonly handle both NGER and ASRS reporting? Carbonly produces NGER-aligned output on AR5 Global Warming Potential values, which is what NGER requires. AASB S2/ASRS directs reporters to AR6, a different GWP set - that gap is a question to put to your auditor on any platform, not something to assume is handled silently.

Which sectors does Carbonly serve? Construction is our lead wedge - it's where the document-processing problem is worst, with fuel dockets and site-based utility bills across dozens of subcontractors. But the same AI pipeline serves property, infrastructure, resources, manufacturing, and any mid-market or enterprise company with mandatory NGER or ASRS obligations.

Does Carbonly sell carbon offsets? No, on purpose. We think a platform that both measures your emissions and sells you the offsets that reduce them has a structural conflict of interest. Carbonly measures. That's it.

Is there a free way to test Carbonly before buying? Yes. Send your last quarter of utility bills to hello@carbonly.ai and we'll process them for free, no credit card or sales call required, so you can see the extracted data and audit trail before committing.

How does Carbonly's pricing work alongside a consultant? Consultants scope and price engagements individually, so we won't put a number on their side of the comparison. The two are not really substitutes: consulting practices can use platforms like Carbonly to carry the record-keeping load so their people spend time on methodology, boundary and assurance strategy instead of data entry. Carbonly prices per project rather than per headcount, with a $100/month workspace minimum, scaling to enterprise multi-site deployments. See the full software cost breakdown for how that sits across the market.

Is ASRS Group 2 reporting actually underway yet? Yes - financial years starting on or after 1 July 2026 now carry mandatory obligations for entities meeting two of three thresholds ($200M+ revenue, $500M+ gross assets, 250+ employees), plus every NGER reporter not already in Group 1. Software and audit-trail readiness matter more now than they did pre-July, because there's no runway left to fix a broken data pipeline before your first disclosure.


Related Reading:

Related articles

AASB S2 figures your assurance provider can trace back to the source

Bring one emission record your team finds hard to evidence. In 30 minutes we show the source document, factor version and change history Carbonly keeps on every record.

Book a 30-minute call Prefer email? hello@carbonly.ai

Per-project pricing, no per-seat fees. We reply within business hours.