Safeguard Mechanism Compliance: Tracking Baselines

In year two of the reformed Safeguard, total exceedance surged 48.9% to 13.7 million tonnes. 140+ facilities are above their baseline and the maths gets worse every July. If you're still tracking your position annually, you're buying ACCUs at whatever price the market gives you.

Carbonly.ai Team November 5, 2026 13 min read
Safeguard MechanismACCUCarbon CreditsComplianceNGEREmissions Tracking
Safeguard Mechanism Compliance: Tracking Baselines

Safeguard Mechanism compliance tracking means monitoring a covered facility's Scope 1 emissions against its declining annual baseline throughout the year - not reconstructing the position once, after the fact, when the NGER report falls due. Done monthly, it turns a September surprise into a decision made with months of lead time to shop the ACCU market. Done annually, it leaves a facility buying credits at whatever price the market offers in the same narrow window every other exceeding facility is also buying.

The stakes are rising fast. The 2024-25 preliminary Safeguard Mechanism data landed in November, and the headline number should worry every covered facility in Australia. Total exceedance across the scheme hit 13.7 million tonnes - up 48.9% from 9.2 million tonnes the year before. More than 140 facilities are now operating above their declining baseline.

That's not a rounding error. That's the ratchet doing exactly what it was designed to do.

Baselines dropped another 4.9%. Emissions didn't drop fast enough to keep up. The 2024-25 compliance deadline - 31 March 2026 - has now passed; facilities in exceedance settled their surrender obligations at whatever ACCU spot price the market offered during that window. The next deadline, for the 2025-26 compliance year, falls on 31 March 2027. ACCU spot prices closed August 2026 at $38.95 (intramonth high $39.50, per CORE Markets), then eased back - Argus assessed generic ACCUs at $38.35 on 2 October 2026 and $37.75 by 20 October 2026. That's still well above the mid-$30s a year earlier, but it's a two-way market, not a straight climb. For a facility 25,000 tonnes over its baseline, that's roughly $943,750 in surrender obligations at the current $37.75 figure - a number that will move again before the March 2027 deadline.

I spent more than 15 years across the Australian resources sector. I've seen Safeguard compliance from both sides - as someone producing the emissions data and as someone trying to make sense of it for reporting. The single biggest problem isn't the regulation itself. It's the timing of information. Most facilities discover their exceedance position months after they could have done something about it. By then, the only option left is buying credits at whatever the market charges.

That's why we built Safeguard Mechanism compliance tracking into Carbonly - not as an annual reconciliation tool, but as a position check you can run whenever new data lands.

The real-view-mirror problem

Here's how Safeguard compliance works at most covered facilities today. Environmental managers collect emissions data through the year. Sometime in September or October, they compile the NGER report. That's when they find out - for the first time with any precision - whether their facility exceeded its baseline for the year that ended three months earlier.

If they did exceed, they have until 31 March to surrender ACCUs or SMCs. That gives them roughly five months to enter the carbon market, negotiate purchases, and settle - all while every other facility in the same position is doing the same thing.

The first year of the reformed scheme showed this pattern clearly. ACCU surrenders jumped from 1.2 million units in 2022-23 to 7.1 million in 2023-24, according to the Carbon Market Institute. Meanwhile, 8.3 million SMCs were issued to 62 facilities that beat their baselines. But SMC usage was less than 20% of issuance - meaning most credits sat in registries rather than being traded.

That's a market where supply exists but information asymmetry drives bad purchasing decisions. If you don't know you're 15,000 tonnes over baseline until October, you can't start sourcing SMCs in July when they're cheaper. You're a price-taker, not a price-maker.

What monthly position tracking actually looks like

The Safeguard Mechanism covers Scope 1 emissions only. That's a narrower scope than full NGER reporting, but it still requires facility-level granularity - and facility-level data collection is where things fall apart.

Consider a facility with a baseline of 120,000 tonnes for FY2025-26 (after the 4.9% decline from the prior year). By the end of each month, you should know three things: your cumulative emissions year-to-date, your pro-rata baseline position at that point, and the gap between them.

In Carbonly, the Safeguard Trajectory Check compares projected emissions with each facility's declining baseline, on demand. A set of blunt status bands is a useful way to read the gap:

  • On track: your cumulative emissions are at or below the pro-rata baseline. No action needed yet.
  • At risk: you're within 5% above baseline. This is the warning zone - close enough that a production spike or a measurement correction could push you over.
  • Exceeding: you're 5% or more above baseline. You need a plan. Now.

The point isn't precision to the tonne in month three. The point is knowing your trajectory early enough to act. If you're trending 8% above baseline by December, you've got three months to source ACCUs before the March 31 deadline - not five panicked weeks.

The ACCU purchasing window

This is where the financial argument lives. ACCU prices don't move in a straight line. EY's Australian Carbon Market Outlook (January 2026) projects spot prices staying in the $30-35 range through 2028, rising gradually toward $70 by 2035. But within any given compliance year, prices swing.

The cost containment price for 2025-26 is $82.68 per ACCU - that's the government's ceiling, where the CER will release units from the Commonwealth's holdings to prevent prices spiking above that level. The secondary market sits well below that today. But we've already seen intra-year volatility: ACCUs traded as high as $42 in late 2024 when Safeguard demand compressed against the compliance window, then settled back to the mid-$30s.

If you're running a cement plant 30,000 tonnes above baseline, the difference between buying ACCUs at $34 in August versus $42 in February is $240,000. That's real money. And it's entirely a function of when you had the information to act.

A useful view puts two numbers side by side: how many credits you're likely to need based on your current trajectory, and the estimated cost at current market prices. It's not a crystal ball. But it turns "we might need to buy some offsets" into "at current run rate, we need 27,400 ACCUs by March 31, which will cost approximately $1,034,350 at today's spot price."

That's a number a CFO can work with.

SMCs: the credit you earn by outperforming

Safeguard Mechanism Credits are the other side of the ledger. When your facility's emissions come in below baseline, the CER issues you SMCs for the difference. In 2023-24, 62 facilities earned a total of 8.3 million SMCs.

Here's what's interesting: the preliminary 2024-25 data shows SMC eligibility dropping 15.7% as baselines tighten. Fewer facilities are beating their baselines by enough to generate credits. That's simple maths - the baseline falls 4.9% every year, so the bar keeps rising.

Track SMC generation potential the same way as exceedance. If your facility is trending 5,000 tonnes below baseline, estimate the SMC issuance and think about whether to bank them for future compliance years or sell them to other Safeguard facilities.

Banking matters more than most people realise. The 2026-27 review will reconsider whether SMCs remain valid past 2030. If you're generating credits now, the smart move might be to hold them rather than sell at today's price - but only if you believe the post-2030 rules will honour them. That's a genuine strategic uncertainty. We don't pretend to know the policy outcome.

Flexibility measures and when to use them

The Safeguard Mechanism isn't just "stay under baseline or buy credits." There are four compliance pathways beyond direct surrender, and many facilities don't fully understand when each one makes sense.

Pathway How it works Cost or catch Best suited to
Borrow from next year Take up to 10% of next year's baseline to cover this year's excess Interest 2% for FY2024-25/FY2025-26, jumping to 10% from FY2026-27 - roughly a five-to-one cost disadvantage against buying ACCUs at current spot prices A short-term timing gap you can genuinely close next year
Multi-year monitoring period (MYMP) Spread compliance across 2-5 years, provided cumulative emissions stay below cumulative baselines over the period Can't extend past 30 June 2030; six facilities used this in 2023-24 A major abatement project (e.g. process-heat electrification) landing in year two or three
Trade-exposed baseline-adjusted (TEBA) Slower decline rate for eligible manufacturers - as low as 1% a year instead of 4.9% Requires an independent audit and a cost-impact demonstration; 17 facilities used this in year one Aluminium, cement and other EITE producers competing with imports from jurisdictions without carbon pricing
Exemption declaration Excess emissions excused entirely Only for natural disasters or criminal activity - very narrow, very rarely used Genuine force-majeure events

The decision tree matters. Software shouldn't automate the choice - these are strategic decisions that need board-level input. What it can do is make the financial comparison clear: "surrender ACCUs now at $37.75/tonne, borrow at 10% interest, or apply for an MYMP and defer the obligation." That comparison only works if your emissions data is current, not nine months stale.

Coal mining: the method transition wildcard

One sector-specific wrinkle deserves its own discussion, because it affects the single largest source of Safeguard exceedance. Coal mining fugitive emissions measurement is undergoing a forced method transition.

Under Method 1, facilities used a default gas content factor of 1.21 m3/t of coal. The problem: actual observed gas content in the Bowen Basin runs 5-12 m3/t - four to ten times higher. The result was systematic undercounting at some mines and overcounting at others.

The outcomes were dramatic. Caval Ridge's reported emissions dropped 90% after switching from Method 1 to Method 2. Hail Creek's went up 3.5 times, according to IEEFA analysis. Since July 2025, mines producing more than 10 million tonnes ROM have had to use Method 2 or higher, and the rest were required to switch by July 2026 - so the transition is now complete across the sector.

For mining companies tracking Safeguard compliance, this creates a forecasting nightmare. Your baseline was set using one measurement method. Your actual emissions might be reported using a different one. If your true emissions are significantly higher than Method 1 suggested, you could go from "comfortably under baseline" to "deeply in exceedance" in a single reporting year - not because anything changed operationally, but because the measurement got more accurate.

This is exactly the kind of scenario where monthly tracking against baseline catches problems before they become $5 million ACCU bills.

The 2026-27 review: planning for uncertainty

Everything I've described above operates under the current rules. Those rules are about to be reviewed.

The 2026-27 Safeguard Mechanism review formally got underway through the Carbon Market Institute's Safeguard Symposium on 4 August 2026, and the government's consultation paper closed for submissions on 18 September 2026. Early advisory reads of that consultation, including from ERM, suggest a full scheme redesign isn't on the table - the focus is squarely on how the mechanism operates past 2030, not on rebuilding it. That matters for planning purposes: the core architecture (declining baselines, ACCU surrender, SMCs) is the thing to build your systems around, not something likely to be replaced wholesale. The review will still examine several foundational questions:

  • Whether the 4.9% annual decline rate is sufficient to meet Australia's 62-70% reduction target by 2035
  • How cost containment should work post-2030 (the current $82.68 ceiling is already under scrutiny)
  • Whether EITE arrangements remain appropriate as international carbon border mechanisms take shape
  • Whether SMCs should be valid beyond 2030
  • Whether the scheme's scope should expand (the Productivity Commission has estimated that extending coverage could deliver over $900 million in national benefits by 2035)

We don't know the outcomes. Nobody does. But we do know that building a reduction plan around the current 4.9% trajectory is the minimum - and you should be modelling scenarios where it accelerates.

A useful model runs the year-by-year baseline trajectory forward to 2030 at 4.9%, then at the current default of 3.285% per year after that, and lets you adjust the decline rate to model what-if scenarios. What if the review sets a 6% decline? What if it introduces a hard cap instead of intensity-adjusted baselines? Those scenarios produce different ACCU demand forecasts and different cost profiles. Having the data infrastructure to run them in hours instead of weeks is worth something.

What we're honest about

We'd be lying if we said monthly tracking solves every compliance problem. It doesn't. Here's what remains genuinely hard.

NGER data lags. The Safeguard Mechanism runs on NGER-reported Scope 1 emissions, and NGER reporting is annual with an October deadline. Your final verified emissions number won't exist until months after the financial year ends. Monthly tracking uses the best available data - fuel records, production logs, process measurements - but it's an estimate until the NGER report is lodged. The gap between a monthly estimate and the final NGER figure depends entirely on your data quality.

Baseline adjustments for production changes are complex. Production-adjusted baselines move with your output. If you ramp up production mid-year, your baseline rises - but by how much depends on your calculated emissions intensity and the CER's assessment. A model can use the published emissions-intensity values, but the CER's final determination might differ.

ACCU price forecasting is inherently uncertain. You can show cost exposure at current spot prices and model different price assumptions. We don't predict where prices will be in six months. EY projects $30-35 through 2028. RepuTex has a slightly different view. The honest answer is that nobody knows, and anyone selling you price certainty is selling you something else.

The 2026-27 review could change the rules. If the decline rate changes, if scope expands, if cost containment is restructured - all bets are off on forward modelling. Until the rules are finalised, model them as they exist today.

The $364-per-tonne penalty you want to avoid

One number concentrates the mind. Under the Safeguard Mechanism, the civil penalty for excess emissions that aren't managed by the compliance deadline is $364 per tonne (one penalty unit, $364 for offences from 1 July 2026) plus $36,400 per day the facility remains in excess.

A facility 10,000 tonnes over baseline faces $3.3 million in penalties plus daily accruals. Compare that to buying 10,000 ACCUs at $37.75 - $377,500. The economics of proactive compliance aren't subtle.

In the first two years of the reformed scheme, no facility has actually been hit with the maximum penalty. The CER has taken a graduated approach - enforceable undertakings, like the one Beach Energy accepted in July 2025, are the preferred tool. The "training wheels" period, as the Carbon Market Institute called it, won't last forever.

Start tracking monthly. Not annually

If your facility emits more than 100,000 tonnes CO2-e and you're still reconciling your Safeguard position once a year when the NGER report is due, you're flying blind into a compliance environment that gets 4.9% harder every July.

The maths: compounding a 4.9% annual decline over six years, your baseline will be roughly 26% lower by FY2029-30 than it was in FY2023-24. Your production probably won't be 26% lower. Something has to give - either your emissions intensity drops through genuine abatement, or you're buying credits. The question is whether you buy them strategically with six months of lead time, or desperately with six weeks.

Get your Scope 1 data flowing monthly. Map it against your declining baseline. Know your position before the market does.

Quick answers

What is Safeguard Mechanism compliance tracking? Monitoring a covered facility's Scope 1 emissions against its declining baseline throughout the compliance year, rather than only discovering the position when the NGER report is lodged months after year-end.

How often should I check my Safeguard position? Monthly, at minimum. Annual reconciliation only tells you where you stood after the ACCU-buying window has already narrowed.

What happens if I exceed my baseline and don't act? You owe a surrender obligation by 31 March the following year - ACCUs, SMCs, or a combination. Left unmanaged past the deadline, the civil penalty is $364 per tonne plus $36,400 per day in continuing excess.

Can I defer the obligation instead of buying ACCUs? Yes, within limits: borrowing against next year's baseline, a multi-year monitoring period, or (for eligible trade-exposed manufacturers) a TEBA determination. Each has a real cost or eligibility test - see the pathway table above.


Related Reading:

Related articles

Emission figures you can trace back to the bill they came from

Bring one utility bill, fuel docket or supplier invoice. In 30 minutes we show the quantities Carbonly reads, the Australian factor each one matches, and the trail an auditor would follow.

Book a 30-minute call Prefer email? hello@carbonly.ai

Per-project pricing, no per-seat fees. We reply within business hours.