Multi-Framework Carbon Reporting: NGER, AASB S2, CDP
One set of emissions figures your NGER report, AASB S2 disclosure, CDP response and GRI report all agree on. Where the frameworks really differ, what each one asks for, and which parts still need a person to write them.
You can give NGER, AASB S2, CDP and GRI the same emissions figures if you keep one dataset and build each report from it. The activity data under all four is the same: fuel burned, electricity bought, refrigerant lost. What differs is the boundary, the GWP set, the Scope 2 method and the narrative around the numbers. Those differences belong in the report layer. When they leak into separate spreadsheets, the totals drift apart and someone has to explain why.
Picture a sustainability team at a listed property company with one spreadsheet per framework. One for NGER, one for the GRI sustainability report, one for CDP and one for AASB S2. Each update lands in one file first. By October, with NGER due and CDP responses being finalised, the totals no longer match. The gap is small, and an assurance practitioner will still ask about it.
Same activity data, four different views of it
The GHG Protocol Corporate Standard sits underneath most of these frameworks. It defines the organisational boundary, the Scope 1, 2 and 3 split and the activity data times factor method. CDP asks for GHG Protocol methodology. AASB S2 refers to it directly. GRI 305 is built on it. NGER uses its own method set in the NGER Measurement Determination, but the activity data is the same.
NGER wants facility-level emissions by gas, by scope and by ANZSIC code, lodged through the CER's EERS system. The 2025-26 report is due by midnight AEDT on Monday 2 November 2026, because 31 October falls on a Saturday. The CER has said there are no extensions. Our NGER October 2026 deadline guide covers the last weeks before lodgement. NGER uses the IPCC AR5 GWP values set in regulation 2.02 of the NGER Regulations.
AASB S2 wants emissions disclosed inside its Governance, Strategy, Risk Management, and Metrics and Targets structure. It asks for location-based Scope 2 plus information about contractual instruments, and for the seven Kyoto gases converted to CO2-e. Its default GWP set is AR6.
CDP wants investor-focused climate data in a questionnaire that changes from year to year. CDP says the questionnaire is aligned with IFRS S2, the international standard AASB S2 is based on. The response window overlaps the NGER deadline season.
GRI 305 wants Scope 1, 2 and 3 in tonnes of CO2-e, biogenic CO2 shown separately, and intensity ratios. GRI uses impact materiality: how your company affects the environment. AASB S2 uses financial materiality: how climate affects your company's prospects. The emissions data can be the same while the reason for disclosing it differs.
So one dataset with facility detail, per-source activity data and a clear record of the factor behind each figure can feed all four reports. The templates need to differ. The dataset does not.
Where the numbers really diverge: GWPs and Scope 2
The largest technical gap is the GWP set. NGER uses AR5: methane at 28 and nitrous oxide at 265. AR6 puts fossil methane at 29.8, non-fossil methane at 27.0 and nitrous oxide at 273. Applying both sets to every source means two parallel calculations.
The AASB approved AASB S2025-1 on 15 December 2025. Our reading is that it lets NGER reporters use AR5 GWPs in their AASB S2 disclosure for the NGER-covered portion of their emissions. The AASB gives its application date as periods beginning on or after 1 January 2027, with early application permitted. Confirm how it applies to your reporting period with your assurance practitioner.
The relief covers the NGER-covered portion only. Overseas operations and facilities below the NGER thresholds may still need AR6 figures. For a domestic-only NGER reporter the gap is now small. For a group with offshore assets it still matters. Our AR5 vs AR6 methane explainer works through the numbers.
Scope 2 is the second gap. NGER's required Scope 2 figure is location-based. AASB S2 requires location-based Scope 2 and asks about contractual instruments such as green power or certificates. CDP asks for both location-based and market-based figures. GRI 305-2 asks for location-based and, where it applies, market-based.
The location-based figure uses the state grid factors in the NGA Factors 2025 workbook. For example, Scope 2 factors are 0.64 kg CO2-e per kWh for NSW and ACT, 0.78 for Victoria and 0.22 for South Australia. A market-based figure starts from the same kWh and applies your contracts and certificates. Keep the kWh once and calculate each method from it.
What one dataset looks like in practice
Every utility bill, fuel docket and supplier invoice becomes an activity record with its source document attached. Each record carries the emission factor and the factor version used to calculate it. Each report then reads from those records.
That is how Carbonly is built. It reads supplier invoices, dockets and utility bills in eight file formats and creates one record per docket on multi-docket invoices. Low-confidence matches and units that need an unstated figure go to a reviewer. Every reported tonne links back to the document it came from, and ledger writes are logged as typed audit events.
The ledger calculates CO2-e with AR5 values, the set NGER requires. The product writes AR5 figures only. If part of your group needs an AR6 figure, that is a separate step to agree with your assurance practitioner.
From the ledger, Carbonly exports an NGER report as XML shaped for EERS, as a reference while you lodge. It also exports AASB S2 material to PDF or Word. NGER facility and corporate group threshold status is computed from the same records. Joint ventures can be consolidated under operational control, financial control or equity share. Periods can be locked, and a restatement records its reason.
We do not offer CDP or GRI templates. Those reports draw on the same totals, entered in each framework's format by your team or your adviser.
What software cannot write for you
Software can supply the quantitative sections: emissions totals, energy data, intensity metrics and progress against targets. A large part of each framework is qualitative.
AASB S2's Governance section asks about board oversight, management roles, skills and how climate links to remuneration. Strategy asks for scenario analysis and transition planning. Risk Management describes how you find and rank climate risks. These sections need people to write them.
CDP's questionnaire changes each year, so last year's answers need checking against the current version. GRI's materiality assessment is its own exercise, because impact materiality and financial materiality can rank the same topic differently. The emissions figure stays the same while the framing around it changes.
Single-dataset reporting removes the re-keying and transcription errors between spreadsheets. The judgement calls stay with your team and your advisers.
The cost of separate spreadsheets is disagreement
Take a mid-sized resources company above the 50 kt CO2-e NGER corporate threshold. It lodges financial reports under Chapter 2M, so its NGER registration brings it into ASRS reporting. A large customer sends it a CDP request, and its investors expect a GRI-aligned sustainability report.
That is four frameworks. If each one is built from a separate data pull, the risk is that the totals disagree. Suppose the NGER report says 47,200 tonnes and the CDP response says 48,100. The cause might be a different period boundary, an electricity factor left on the 2024 NGA edition, or a facility counted twice after a mid-year sale.
An assurance practitioner working to ASSA 5010 is likely to ask about that gap. A public CDP response that disagrees with an AASB S2 disclosure also invites questions about which figure is right. Building every report from the same records lets you trace each figure back to one source and explain any intended difference, such as a boundary or GWP choice.
The frameworks are converging, and the reports stay distinct
The TCFD was disbanded in October 2023 and its recommendations carried into the ISSB standards, which AASB S2 is based on. You can read more in our ASRS, TCFD and GRI comparison. CDP has aligned with IFRS S2. The GHG Protocol sits under all of them.
NGER remains a regulatory scheme with its own Act, its own Measurement Determination and its own regulator, the Clean Energy Regulator. For an entity that lodges financial reports under Chapter 2M, NGER registration now also brings mandatory ASRS reporting. GRI remains the framework for impact materiality, which AASB S2 does not cover. CDP adds the request from investors or customers and a scoring process.
The data requirements are converging and the outputs remain separate. A single dataset with one report per framework fits that. Some groups also face TNFD or the EU's CSRD, so the number of frameworks is unlikely to fall soon.
Start with your NGER data and build outward
If you report under NGER, you already hold the most detailed dataset of the four. It is facility-level and by gas, with energy production and consumption. AASB S2 is disclosed at entity level, though an assurance practitioner will want to see the facility build-up. CDP asks sector-specific questions, and GRI needs impact materiality context.
Get your NGER data right first, with every facility figure traced to its source documents. Keep each kWh once and calculate Scope 2 by each method from it. Then build each framework's report from that one dataset.
If your team keeps more than one spreadsheet for the same emissions data, email hello@carbonly.ai and we will show you one ledger on your own documents.
Related Reading:
- NGER October 2026 Deadline: A Month-by-Month Preparation Guide
- ASRS vs TCFD vs GRI: Which Framework Do You Actually Need?
- How to Generate an AASB S2 Climate Disclosure Report
- NGER Report: What Section 19 Actually Demands
- CDP Disclosure Automation: How to Submit Without the Pain
- How to Run a Climate Materiality Assessment Under AASB S2