Financed Emissions: Carbon Accounting for Financial Services

Financed emissions run about 750 times a bank's operational footprint. A first-year disclosure that survives assurance starts with listed equity, accepts PCAF Score 4 on business loans and says so. How attribution works by asset class and what APRA expects.

Carbonly.ai Team June 30, 2026 Updated 10 November 2026 14 min read
Financed EmissionsPCAFFinancial ServicesScope 3ASRSAPRACarbon Accounting
Financed Emissions: Carbon Accounting for Financial Services

Here's a number that should unsettle every risk team in Australian banking: CDP analysis of disclosing institutions has put financed emissions - the carbon embedded in lending and investment portfolios - at on average 750 times larger than a financial institution's direct operational footprint. In North America, that ratio hits 11,000 times. Your office electricity, company cars, and flights are a footnote. The real emissions sit in the loans you wrote.

And now Australia wants you to count them.

ASRS mandatory climate reporting is pulling financial institutions into Scope 3 Category 15 disclosure whether they're ready or not. Asset owners managing $5 billion or more in funds are ASRS Group 2 by default - reporting for financial years from 1 July 2026. Entities above the Group 1 thresholds started with financial years from 1 January 2025. Every APRA-regulated entity with significant lending or investment portfolios will eventually need to measure financed emissions in Australia, disclose them publicly, and defend the methodology under assurance.

We build carbon accounting technology, and we'll be honest: financed emissions are the single hardest problem in this field. Harder than tracking diesel across construction sites. Harder than collecting Scope 3 data from reluctant suppliers. Because you're not measuring what your own business does - you're measuring what thousands of borrowers and portfolio companies do, often with patchy data and incomplete reporting from their end.

This article is about the mechanics. How financed emissions actually get calculated, asset class by asset class. Where the data breaks down. What APRA and the AASB expect. And what a realistic first-year disclosure looks like when you can't get perfect data from every counterparty in your book.

Your Carbon Footprint Is Your Loan Book

For a manufacturer, carbon accounting starts with gas bills and diesel tanks. For a bank, it starts with the general ledger.

Every dollar you lend to a coal-fired power station, a cattle farmer, a property developer, or a logistics fleet carries an attributed share of that borrower's emissions. The same applies to every equity holding in your investment portfolio, every mortgage on your book, every infrastructure project you financed. Financed emissions account for over 99% of a typical financial institution's total greenhouse gas inventory. The other 1% - Scope 1 and 2 from your branches and data centres - barely registers.

This is Scope 3 Category 15 under the GHG Protocol. And it's the category that turns financial services carbon accounting from a facilities management exercise into a data infrastructure problem.

The methodology that's become the global standard is PCAF - the Partnership for Carbon Accounting Financials. Started by 14 Dutch banks in 2015, it now has over 700 signatories worldwide. In December 2025, PCAF released its third edition, expanding from seven to ten asset classes and adding methodologies for securitisations, use-of-proceeds structures, and sub-sovereign debt. The standard is the reference point for AASB S2 financed emissions disclosure.

Here's the core formula. It's simple in concept and brutal in execution:

Financed Emissions = Attribution Factor x Borrower/Investee Emissions

The attribution factor determines what share of a company's total emissions gets allocated to your institution, based on how much of that company's financing you provided. The borrower's emissions are their actual (or estimated) Scope 1, 2, and - where available - Scope 3.

But that formula hides enormous complexity. The attribution factor calculation differs for every asset class. The borrower emissions data ranges from audited CDP disclosures to pure guesswork based on sector averages. And you need to do this across potentially tens of thousands of exposures.

How the Calculation Works Across Asset Classes

PCAF defines methodologies for different types of financial assets. The attribution factor - the fraction of borrower emissions you claim as yours - works differently depending on the asset class. Here's how.

Listed Equity and Corporate Bonds. The attribution factor is your outstanding investment amount divided by the company's Enterprise Value Including Cash (EVIC). If you hold $50 million of shares in a mining company with a $10 billion EVIC, you attribute 0.5% of that company's emissions to yourself. The data is relatively available here because listed companies increasingly report emissions. But EVIC fluctuates daily with share price, which means your financed emissions can swing materially without a single physical change in the real world. That's a disclosure headache - do you use year-end EVIC, average EVIC, or point-in-time? PCAF recommends using the investee's most recently available EVIC.

Business Loans and Unlisted Equity. Same principle, but the denominator switches to the borrower's total equity plus debt at book value. If you extended a $20 million facility to a private company with $100 million in total balance sheet financing, you attribute 20% of their emissions. The data problem is worse here because private companies rarely report emissions. You're often working with ANZSIC sector averages and revenue proxies instead of actual data.

Mortgages. Attribution is based on the outstanding loan amount divided by the property value at origination. A $600,000 mortgage on an $800,000 home means you attribute 75% of that building's operational emissions. The emissions themselves come from estimated energy use based on property characteristics - floor area, building type, energy rating, location. Australia's residential building stock is wildly inconsistent, from NatHERS 2-star homes built in the 1970s to 7-star new builds. Getting reliable per-dwelling emissions without actual energy consumption data is a significant estimation challenge.

Project Finance. You attribute emissions based on your share of total project financing. If your bank provided $200 million of a $1 billion LNG project's total debt and equity, you attribute 20% of the project's emissions. The difference from business loans is that project finance has a known use of proceeds - you know exactly what the money built. That makes the emissions calculation more targeted but also more exposed to scrutiny, because the assets are identifiable.

Commercial Real Estate. Similar to mortgages but for income-producing property - offices, retail, industrial. Attribution is loan outstanding divided by property value. Emissions come from the building's operational energy use. This is one area where Australian data is improving, because NABERS ratings give you a direct energy intensity benchmark for office buildings. But not every commercial property has a NABERS rating, and the ones that don't tend to be the worst performers.

Motor Vehicle Loans. Attribution is loan outstanding divided by vehicle value. Emissions come from estimated annual kilometres driven and the vehicle's fuel consumption or electricity use. Fleet lending portfolios can use actual fuel card data if available, which pushes data quality up significantly.

The Data Quality Problem Is the Whole Problem

Financed emissions makes every other carbon data problem look small. When you're calculating Scope 2 from electricity bills, at least you have the bill. When you're doing financed emissions, you often have nothing but a loan balance and an industry code.

PCAF's data quality scoring system acknowledges this honestly. It runs from Score 1 (best) to Score 5 (worst):

Score 1 - Verified, audited emissions reported directly by the borrower. Think: a listed company with a CDP A-list disclosure and third-party assurance on their emissions data. This is rare even for large corporates.

Score 2 - Unverified self-reported emissions from the borrower. They gave you numbers but nobody's checked them. Most ASX200 company data sits here. PCAF also scores emissions you calculate from the borrower's own energy consumption data at Score 2.

Score 3 - You calculate emissions from the borrower's production data, such as tonnes of output, and apply emission factors yourself. Reading a borrower's utility bills and fuel invoices helps one level up, because PCAF scores energy-based calculations at Score 2.

Score 4 - Sector-average emissions intensity applied to the borrower's revenue. You know the company is in the "road freight" sector and made $50 million in revenue, so you multiply by the sector's average emissions intensity per dollar of revenue. This is where most business loan portfolios sit today.

Score 5 - Pure proxy estimates with minimal data. You know the loan size and maybe the ANZSIC code, and that's it. This is where SME lending portfolios live, and it's where the numbers are least reliable.

Here's the uncomfortable truth about Australian financial services right now: for most institutions, the weighted average data quality score across their lending book is probably sitting between 3.5 and 4.5. The listed equity portfolio will score better (more reported data). The residential mortgage book and SME lending will score worse.

And that matters, because AASB S2 and the assurance framework don't just want a number - they want you to disclose your data quality. Your auditor will ask how much of your financed emissions total is based on verified data versus sector proxies. A disclosure that says "87% of our financed emissions are estimated using Score 4-5 data" is technically compliant but also a flashing signal to investors and regulators that the number could be materially wrong.

We're not sure there's a shortcut here. Improving data quality means either getting borrowers to report better data (slow, requires engagement programs, and many SMEs don't have the capacity) or getting access to their actual utility and operational data to calculate emissions on their behalf. That second approach is where we think the industry needs to go - and it's where carbon accounting software that can process primary source documents at scale becomes genuinely useful for financial institutions, not just for the borrowers themselves.

What APRA Actually Expects

APRA's Prudential Practice Guide CPG 229, finalised in November 2021, established the framework for how banks, insurers, and super funds should manage climate-related financial risks. It doesn't mandate a specific emissions measurement methodology. But it makes the direction unmistakably clear.

In APRA's 2024 Climate Risk Self-Assessment Survey - covering 149 APRA-regulated entities - 54% reported having set at least one climate-related target, with financed emissions among the most common basis for target-setting. That means over half of surveyed institutions are already committing to financed emissions targets before ASRS even requires them to disclose the numbers.

But APRA also found that metrics and targets, and disclosure, were the weakest areas of CPG 229 alignment across the sector. Governance and risk management scored better. The actual counting - the financed emissions measurement - lagged behind.

APRA isn't standing still. It has consulted on amending Prudential Standards CPS 220 and SPS 220 to explicitly include climate risk. That moves climate from guidance (CPG 229 is a practice guide, not a binding standard) to prudential requirements. The message is that measuring financed emissions isn't optional for APRA-regulated entities, and the regulatory ratchet only tightens from here.

For superannuation funds specifically, the exposure is enormous. Australia's super system holds over $4 trillion in assets, and several of the largest funds have publicly committed to net zero portfolio emissions by 2050. These targets are meaningless without reliable financed emissions measurement, and the ASRS framework will require the numbers behind the promises.

The ASRS Layer: What Financial Institutions Must Disclose

AASB S2 requires entities engaged in financial activities - asset management, commercial banking, insurance - to disclose financed emissions as part of their Scope 3 Category 15 reporting. This isn't a suggestion. It's a specific requirement in the standard.

Here's the timeline that matters:

Asset owners with $5 billion or more in funds under management are carved into ASRS Group 2 - reporting for financial years beginning on or after 1 July 2026. They're explicitly excluded from Group 1, so even very large super funds and registered schemes begin reporting with Group 2. They get a one-year deferral on Scope 3, meaning financed emissions become mandatory in their second reporting year (FY28 for most).

A bank that meets the Group 1 thresholds reports for financial years starting from 1 January 2025. Scope 3 disclosure, including financed emissions, is deferred for its first reporting year only.

In December 2025, the AASB approved amendments (AASB S2025-1) that provide some practical relief for financial institutions:

You can limit Category 15 disclosure to financed emissions only - excluding derivatives, facilitated emissions, and insurance-associated emissions unless you choose to report them or your regulator requires it. That's a meaningful scope reduction.

You don't have to use GICS (the Global Industry Classification Standard) to disaggregate financed emissions by industry. You can use ANZSIC or another system that fits your portfolio better. For Australian banks, this is a practical win because ANZSIC is already embedded in lending systems.

The December 2025 amendments also allow jurisdictional relief on GHG measurement methods and global warming potential values. NGER uses AR5 GWP values; AASB S2 technically requires AR6. That mismatch creates real headaches, and the amendments give some flexibility here.

But here's what the amendments don't change: you still need to disclose absolute gross financed emissions, disaggregated by Scope 1, Scope 2, and Scope 3 of your borrowers and investees, broken out by industry and asset class. That's a massive data aggregation exercise. And the modified liability framework protects Scope 3 disclosures from private litigation for three years - but ASIC can still act, and after 31 December 2027, full liability applies.

A Realistic First-Year Approach

If you're a mid-market insurer, a regional bank, or a $5B+ super fund staring down your first financed emissions disclosure, here's what a realistic first year looks like. Not the aspirational version. The version that survives assurance.

Start with your listed equity and corporate bond portfolio. Data quality will be highest here. Most ASX200 companies report emissions. Many are verified. You'll get Score 1-2 data for a meaningful portion. Use EVIC-based attribution. This gives your assurance provider something solid to anchor on.

For business loans, accept that Score 4 is your starting point. Map your commercial lending book by ANZSIC code. Apply sector-average emissions intensity factors from PCAF's database or from published Australian data. Prioritise your top 20-30 exposures by loan value for direct engagement - ask them for actual emissions data or at least energy consumption data you can convert. That gets your biggest loans to Score 2-3 and moves the needle on your weighted data quality.

Mortgages are a volume game. You might have 100,000 home loans on your book. You won't get individual energy data for each one. Use state-based average residential emissions factors, adjusted for property type and size where you have the data. NatHERS ratings help where available. Accept Score 4-5 for the bulk of the book and disclose that transparently.

Disclose your data quality. PCAF requires it. Your auditor will ask for it. And honestly, transparent disclosure of Score 3-5 data quality in year one is far better than claiming precision you don't have. The modified liability framework gives Scope 3 statements temporary protection from private litigation. What it doesn't protect is numbers that your board signed off on without understanding the methodology behind them.

Document your improvement plan. Show how you intend to move from Score 4-5 towards Score 2-3 over three to five years. Which sectors will you prioritise for engagement? What data infrastructure are you building? This is the direction APRA's guidance points - not perfection, but a credible trajectory.

One view we hold from building carbon accounting tools: the institutions that start with honest, well-documented estimates in year one build the trust and the systems to produce better numbers in year three. The ones that wait for perfect data never report at all.

Where We Fit - and Where We Don't

What Carbonly gives a bank is better input data: a commercial borrower's Scope 1 and 2 figures taken from their own utility bills and fuel invoices rather than a sector average. We should be transparent about the limits. Our strength is extracting emissions data from utility bills, fuel invoices, and operational documents using AI, and that capability maps well to Score 2 data quality in PCAF's table - taking a borrower's actual energy consumption data and calculating emissions from it.

For a bank running a borrower engagement program, Carbonly is designed to help your commercial clients get their Scope 1 and 2 numbers from source documents with less manual effort, whether they work alone or with a consultant. That feeds directly into your financed emissions calculation as higher-quality input data.

But Carbonly also has capabilities that map directly to how financial institutions manage climate data internally. Our JV consolidation supports equity-share emission allocation - the same attribution logic that underpins financed emissions. For fund managers co-investing in assets alongside other institutions, this means you can model the shared ownership structure and allocate emissions by equity share, which mirrors the PCAF attribution factor methodology at the asset level. It doesn't replace a portfolio-level aggregation engine, but it gives you clean, auditable emission allocations for your directly held and co-invested assets.

For institutions setting targets, Carbonly supports intensity targets tracked against the ledger. Financial institutions face specific SBTi requirements - the SBTi Financial Institutions framework requires portfolio-level targets - and tracking progress against those targets needs a system that connects your emissions data to your commitment, not a slide deck updated once a year. Ledger writes are recorded as typed audit events, so when your assurance provider asks how a number changed, the answer is in the system - not in someone's email archive.

We don't build portfolio-level financed emissions aggregation engines today. That's a different product - one that sits on top of your lending system, pulls exposure data, matches it to borrower emissions (however sourced), applies attribution factors by asset class, and produces the disaggregated disclosure AASB S2 requires. Large banks typically build or buy those systems themselves. Mid-market institutions will need to decide whether to build, buy, or cobble together spreadsheets. (We know which option we'd pick. And we know which one most will actually choose.)

The honest gap in the market right now is at the borrower level. If you could get 500 of your largest commercial borrowers to accurately report their emissions, your financed emissions data quality would improve dramatically overnight. That's the piece we're working on - making it so easy for a borrower to produce an emissions number that there's no excuse not to.

The Greenwashing Risk Nobody Talks About

Here's a risk that sits outside the accounting methodology but is just as real: every financed emissions target your institution publishes is a greenwashing exposure.

When a bank says it's reducing financed emissions in its fossil fuel portfolio, or when a super fund commits to net zero by 2050, those are environmental claims. ASIC's media release reports a $12.9 million penalty against Vanguard Investments Australia for misleading claims about ESG exclusionary screens. A second ASIC release reports a $10.5 million penalty against Active Super, which held securities its ESG screens were said to exclude.

If your financed emissions methodology is built on Score 5 estimates and you're publishing targets against those numbers, you're making claims you can't substantiate. That's exactly the pattern regulators have taken to court.

The fix is boringly simple: match the precision of your claims to the quality of your data. If your weighted average data quality is Score 4, don't publish sector-level reduction targets with implied decimal-point precision. Say what you know, disclose what you estimated, and show how you're getting better.


Financed emissions aren't going away. APRA has consulted on moving climate into binding prudential standards. ASRS is making Category 15 disclosure mandatory. The PCAF methodology will keep evolving - the third edition's expansion to ten asset classes signals a standard that's becoming more detailed, not less.

The institutions that start measuring now - even imperfectly - will be the ones that can actually manage their climate risk exposure in three to five years. The ones that treat this as a compliance checkbox will keep being surprised when the numbers tell a story their board wasn't expecting.

The quality of your financed emissions disclosure is only ever as good as the data your borrowers give you, and right now most of them are giving you nothing. Nobody solves that overnight. If you're a bank or super fund and want to see what a borrower's Scope 1 and 2 looks like when it comes from their own bills, email hello@carbonly.ai.

FAQ

What are financed emissions for a bank? Financed emissions are the share of borrower and investee emissions attributed to a bank's lending and investment. They are reported as Scope 3 Category 15 under the GHG Protocol. They account for over 99% of a typical financial institution's greenhouse gas inventory. Scope 1 and 2 from branches and data centres make up the small remainder.

How does a bank calculate financed emissions on a business loan? Multiply the borrower's emissions by an attribution factor. For business loans, the factor is the outstanding loan divided by the borrower's total equity plus debt at book value. A $20 million facility to a company with $100 million in balance sheet financing attributes 20% of its emissions to the lender. Private companies rarely report emissions, so many lenders start with sector averages by ANZSIC code.

What do PCAF data quality scores mean? They rate how reliable the emissions data behind each exposure is, from Score 1 (best) to Score 5 (worst). Score 1 is verified emissions reported by the borrower, and Score 2 is unverified reported data or emissions calculated from the borrower's energy use. Score 3 is calculated from the borrower's production data. Score 4 applies sector-average intensity to revenue. Score 5 is a proxy estimate from little more than loan size and industry code.

When do Australian super funds and asset owners have to disclose financed emissions? Asset owners with $5 billion or more in funds under management report in ASRS Group 2. That covers financial years beginning on or after 1 July 2026. They get a one-year deferral on Scope 3, so financed emissions become mandatory in the second reporting year. AASB S2025-1 lets an entity limit Category 15 disclosure to financed emissions, leaving out derivatives, facilitated emissions and insurance-associated emissions.

What emissions data will a bank ask a business or farm borrower for? Expect a request for actual emissions data, or for the energy and fuel records behind it. A lender working through its book starts with its largest exposures by loan value. The request reaches farms too, since a loan to a cattle farmer carries an attributed share of that farm's emissions. Energy data the lender can convert lifts a loan from a sector average toward PCAF Score 2 or 3. Carbonly is designed to help a commercial borrower produce Scope 1 and 2 figures from utility bills and fuel invoices.


Related Reading:

Related articles

Supplier invoices turned into Scope 3 line items you can show an auditor

Bring one subcontractor invoice, concrete docket or freight bill. In 30 minutes we show the quantities Carbonly reads from it, the factor or EPD each line matches, and the source document behind every tonne.

Book a 30-minute call Prefer email? hello@carbonly.ai

Per-project pricing, no per-seat fees. We reply within business hours.